By Robert Semelsberger
Every movie season there is one director that makes a movie that will make him/her a house hold name and be remarked in the industry as a “heavy hitter,” or “the next big thing.” One single movie can express a director’s passion, creativity, and ability to convey a story. The year 1975 introduced the world to future Oscar-winner Steven Spielberg when he scared the living daylights out of the movie going audience with his first feature film, Jaws. In a similar fashion the world became familiar with director James Cameron in 1986 when he stunned audiences and movie execs with his low-budget Terminator movie, which would later spawn a long running franchise. The 90s brought a swarm of new innovative directors such as Quentin Tarantino and The Coen Brothers, but it was one director that captivated the hearts and souls of audience members around the globe: M. Night Shyamalan.
The year was 1999; the movie was The Sixth Sense. What made the film such a success? The movie held elements of fear, suspense and all around shock. The twist ending to the movie caught almost every viewer off guard and for the most part put the icing on an already fulfilling cake. Since the film was written, produced, and directed by Shyamalan every part of the story and creativity can be credited to him. Critics were taken by this film. Felix Vasquez Jr. from Cinema Crazed called the film “an excellent premiere for new director M. Night Shyamalan as he packs a punch with a great story, excellent directing, a great cast, great performances, and a surprise ending that will leave you breathless for days on end.” Lisa Alspector of the Chicago Reader called the film “M. Night Shyamalan neutralizes Willis’s star presence with impressive plotting that’s a fine excuse for the powerful atmosphere.” Soon Shyamalan would be the go to man in Hollywood if a complex and thrilling film was wanted. Some professionals named Shyamalan “the new Spielberg.” However, a director shouldn’t be judged solely on one movie.
As the years continued on, Shyamalan kept churning out movies, but the “creativity” he once expressed started shifting from complex and innovative to goofy and over-the- top. The main problem is that Shyamalan attempted to capture the thrills and twists he had with The Sixth Sense, but instead was one step closer to a living example that lightning only strikes once. In the movie Signs, aliens terrorize a small family on a farm. Towards the end of the movie the Shyamalan twist is revealed: The aliens’ only weakness is water. This could be one of the weakly thought out plot twists in current movie making. Why would the aliens invade a planet that is 70 percent their only weakness? Even if they killed all of mankind on earth they still wouldn’t be able to leave the continent their on. According to Shyamalan’s twist the only thing the planet needs to conquer extra-terrestrials is an arsenal of super soaker. Plus the aliens are weaklings who can easily be defeated by young man with a baseball bat. This lame twist to an already mediocre movie is just the beginning of a steady decline that is Shyamalan’s movie career.
Shyamalan’s next movie was a little film called The Village. It wasn’t a terrible concept for a movie a small Amish village is terrorized on random nights by a swarm of evil monsters in long red robes that resemble strange prehistoric hogs. Unfortunately, the movie didn’t live up to its concept. The movie is a mess and as things attempt to get more complex it just manages to become more and more ridiculous. As Shyamalan attempts to put his signature “twist” in the movie, which reveals that the whole village isn’t really an old Amish village but instead a the middle of a huge wildlife preserve that lies in the middle of a city. The second “twist” is that the monsters mentioned before don’t really exist but are instead the elderly villagers dressed up to give the impression they are monsters to try and keep their people from leaving the village. The twists lead to asking more questions than answering them. Once again it looks like Shyamalan’s signature plot twists had destroyed his movie, but it wasn’t until long for his next set of films to show problems much more than just their plot twists.
After Shyamalan’s first break out of the thriller/horror genre was his “epic bed time story” titled Lady in the Water. Considered to be Shyamalan’s first real flop, the movie was neither welcomed by critics or audiences. Film critic, Jamie Gillies, for the Apollo Guide wrote “the film is a mess, a ramshackle affair. Its silliness cannot sustain itself”. One of its problems was the difficulty Warner Bros. would have marketing the film. Lady in the Water was supposed to appeal to a wider audience than Shyamalan’s previous features, but the film was a little too dark and scary to solely market to Disney Channel loving tweens. It seems M. Night Shyamalan would try to over compensate with his next film, spinning in a complete 180 degree turn, switching from magical fantasy to suspense-filled, disaster flick. His next film was the film that could hopefully rekindle the flame that was Shyamalan’s credibility in the movie industry as well as deliver his most emotional and fear-inducing film since The Sixth Sense. Those hopes managed to be completely false when The Happening hit theaters in summer 2008. Almost everything in this “movie” is stupid and beyond ridiculous. The movie centers around “killer air” that sweeps around the world and causes its victims to drop dead instantly. Not only does the storyline lack any depth, but it also lacks any basic sense. How can air sweep through a city and only kill certain people not everyone? Secondly, throughout the movie Mark Walberg leads a band of survivors to try and escape the air. How can people run from air? Shyamalan must not understand that air is every way and if one were to “escape it” they would still die from suffocation. It is this type of laziness that has been attributed to Shyamalan in recent years.
Shyamalan was coming off a series of box office and critical bombs so he decided there was only one logical option: Adapt a Nickelodeon cartoon into a live action franchise. Like he had done once before, Shyamalan broke out of the dark, thriller genre into a more family friendly story. He wanted to take an already popular cartoon (Avatar: The Last Airbender) and basically destroy all the charm and creativity that the show conveyed. Maybe that wasn’t his intention, but that’s how it turned out when audiences got a wiff of the stink bomb that was The Last Airbender in 2010. Not only was the movie a terrible excuse for a movie, but it was a terrible excuse for an adaptation of the much beloved TV show. Shyamalan changed a number of things from the original cartoon that it would make fans of the series cringe; this included the incorrect pronunciation of almost all the characters names. Shyamalan even got mass criticism before the movie was even released when he cast white actors to play characters of Native American decent. Shyamalan tried to argue that he overlooked the ethnicity issues because the actors were “right for the part,” but in the movies it is clear that the kids in the movie can’t act very well. It was later revealed that the lead actor, Noah Ringer, was only cast because he had a martial arts background and in reality he had never even acted in a film before. Maybe Mr. Ringer’s acting wouldn’t have suffered so much if the lines he was reading were any good, but the script (written in part by Shyamalan) lacked any substance or critical thinking. At points certain characters give long monologues that summarize what just happened in a scene along just in case the audience didn’t understand. Furthermore, Shyamalan adds an unnecessary narrative that summarizes subplots that are barely shown on screen. The narration acts as a way for Shyamalan to condense 20 episodes of a season into one, short 90-minute movie. With a narration he can explain every little thing that is presented in the show, but here it only leaves the audience with nauseating confusion.
What’s next in store for M. Night Shyamalan, the man who was once labeled “the new Spielberg”? That is yet to be determined. Maybe he’ll try his hand at a comedy now that he realized that most people laughed their way out of the theater when they saw The Happening. Maybe Shyamalan will adapt a Shakespearean play such as Hamlet or Romeo & Juliet. Maybe Shyamalan will do the scariest thing of all and create a second part to The Last Airbender Saga. Whatever Shyamalan’s next film happens to be, if it’s on par with his latest series of flops then the American public should prepare themselves for an apocalyptic result at their local theater.